THE COMMENTARIART has spoken, Miliband was dull, boring and did not look like a Prime Minister in waiting.
They are right in the sense it was dull and boring as a whole but Prime Ministerial? Yes I think so, quiet and unassuming but with more gravitas than the previous 'Quiet Man' Iain Duncan Smith.
What they fail to appreciate is how the speech came across on the news channels, who need soundbites not great long diatribes.
On that Miliband scored big in my opinion, the line about Cameron not lying awake worried about the UK but about UKIP will have hurt and resonated with many voters.
And on Europe, Miliband's attack lines on Cameron would not only resonate with voters but with the Carswell section of the Conservatives who don't believe the Prime Minister is serious about reforming the
He was silly forgetting the deficit and immigration lines from the speech, his memory capacity is admirable but an Autocue is sometimes your best friend.
But those issues are front and centre of UK's voters minds so Miliband will have to talk about it between now and polling day.
Where Miliband was clever was in the use of the NHS, any Labour leader knows if they stroke the NHS,
the members purr and the Tories cower.
The Mansion Tax - tobacco tax – hedge fund tax policy is economically sound and would provide a great big cash cow for the National Health Service.
As long as the party continues to press ahead with it, that alone should ensure Labour's core vote will at least have to think very hard before crossing to UKIP.
And it's a clever policy, it dares the Conservatives to oppose it knowing full well should they oppose they will be painted as the party of the rich and privileged and not caring about the NHS.
Thanks to the gift that keeps giving that is Grant Shapps, Labour are already ahead as the Conservatives released a poster saying Labour wanted to tax 'your family home'.....I I'd missed all those mansions in inner
city London and Birmingham!
The criticism of the commentariart surprises me, we need to stop judging the parties on their conferences, a
social gathering for four days.
I will be judging Cameron, Miliband and Clegg when the Prime Minister dissolves parliament for the election.
Only then should we assess those in the running for the biggest job in the country.